Leasing vs. renting a car
While both options let you drive a car without buying it, leasing is a long-term commitment (typically 2-4 years) through a dealership with monthly payments, mileage limits, and a requirement to carry your own insurance. Renting is a short-term solution available through rental agencies, offering more flexibility with pay-as-you-go pricing and optional insurance. Choosing between the two comes down to how long you need the car, your budget, and how much flexibility you want.
Explore Progressive Answers' auto editorial guidelines to find out why you can trust the car insurance information you find here.
Leasing vs. renting a car: What's the difference?
| Leasing | Renting | |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership | LeasingYou don't own the vehicle | RentingYou don't own the vehicle |
| Length of use | LeasingLong-term (typically 2-4 years) | RentingShort-term (a day to several months) |
| Cost structure | LeasingMonthly payments, possible down payment, early termination fees | RentingDaily/weekly rate, pay-as-you-go |
| Mileage restrictions | LeasingStrict mileage limits, overages may result in fees | RentingMay have mileage limits, but often more flexible |
| Customization | LeasingUsually not allowed | RentingNot allowed |
| Insurance requirements | LeasingMust carry your own insurance | RentingMay be covered by a personal auto policy or rental insurance purchased at checkout |
| Best for | LeasingDrivers needing a longer-term vehicle without buying | RentingTravelers or short-term needs |
| Commitment level | LeasingHigh: contractual agreement with penalties for early exit | RentingLow: flexible, no long-term contract |
Pros and cons of leasing vs. renting a car
If you're looking to drive the same car for a couple years without buying a new car, a lease may make more sense than renting. Keep in mind that entering a lease involves a down payment followed by monthly payments for the lease term. Consider these pros and cons of leasing a car:
Pros of leasing a car
- Leasing gives you a wider selection of cars: When leasing a car through a dealership, you'll have the choice between most of their car models. Rental companies generally have a smaller selection and can't guarantee an exact model.
- Leasing may cost less than renting for long-term use: You'll typically pay less per month on a lease versus a rental car of the same model for the same amount of time.
- You can buy the car at the end of your lease: Some lease agreements let you buy out your car lease. Once your lease ends, you can pay for the rest of the car's value (as set in your lease terms), and the car will be yours.
Cons of leasing a car
- Lease terms are two years or more: If you want a car for a shorter period, a lease may not be right for you.
- It takes time to finalize a contract: More paperwork is generally required when leasing vs. renting a car. Many lessors may also look at your credit score and income to help ensure you can make the monthly payments.
- Higher upfront and long-term financial commitment: Leases often require a down payment and monthly payments for the full lease term. If your needs change, you may end up paying for a car you no longer want or use.
How does insurance work when leasing vs. renting a car?
If you have a personal auto insurance policy, it often covers rental cars. If not, or if you want extra protection, the rental company will offer insurance options at checkout. When leasing a car, you must carry your own insurance. At a minimum, you must meet your state's car insurance coverage requirements, but many leasing companies require additional car lease insurance coverage because they still own the vehicle.
Quote car insurance online or give us a call
Learn more about car insurance policies.
